BBPR - Targeted Lifestyle Communications

BBPR - Targeted Lifestyle Communications

Archive for the ‘social media’ Category

Why Social Media Should Not Replace Real Journalism

Wednesday, August 11th, 2010

BBPR Social Media San Diego PR Marketing

If you’re on Facebook, you’ve probably seen the story of “Jenny Dry Erase” a woman who quit her job for various reasons that most people seemed to applaud her for (at least most of my friends on Facebook).  And if you’re like many of my friends (and myself included), you thought the piece was real… or almost real.

Well, it wasn’t. See here for Tech Crunch’s follow-up.

Jenny was a hoax… like the Taco Bell buying the Liberty Bell (something a previous agency I worked at came up with – but I was not involved in the campaign).  The company involved fooled a lot of us with “Jenny Dry Erase”.  Or just me and my friends. I feel a little ripped off because they didn’t sell me something in the process… but I digress.

“Jenny Dry Erase” is a prime example of why we should never allow real journalistic-based media to go away.  Media outlets that check sources, follow-up on leads and vet ideas for newsworthy-ness prior to even considering them for publication are incredibly important.  Sites such as Wikipedia are great for looking things up, but whose to say that 10 minutes before you looked up “public relations” I didn’t go on there and make a post about BBPR or all of the great work we’ve done (some of which can be seen here).

What’s real anyway?  Many people agree that you should support “official” charities rather than say, give money to a homeless guy on the street.

Bill Byrne San Diego action sports PR

But how do we know this guys family really wasn’t killed by ninjas?  Ok, they probably weren’t.  But how do you know guys with more believeable signage are really homeless veterans or are going to spend the money you give them on food instead of booze, etc.?  You don’t.  But at the same time, we’ve seen in the news that not all charities are what they appear either… but since they seem more official, some people are more comfortable supporting them.

Now I’m not saying that everything media outlets publish is factual or without slant.  There are things to consider, such as personal agendas (CNN is very different than Fox News and Transworld SURF is different from Surfer, etc.), advertisers and the influence of PR people (ahem).  BUT, before you begin citing what’s on the SLAP message boards or Joe Blog.com as fact, keep in mind that you may really know where this information is coming from or if the person behind the writing has a personal reason for creating the content.  What’s their track record for reporting the facts, embellishment and/or glorification of sensationalistic stories?

BTW – this is NOT a slag on bloggers.  We work with online media… bloggers and others… regularly.   Just wanted to draw attention to this recent example of how something posted on the Internet was assumed to be true… because it was posted on the Internet and looked “nice.”

If you believe this, we have a $20,000 a month retainer contract just waiting for you to sign!

If you believe this JPG, we have a $20,000 a month retainer contract just waiting for you to sign…

PR People – We’re Not the Bad Guys

Wednesday, April 14th, 2010

Sometimes PR people can get a bad reputation.

BBPR  San Diego Lifestyle PR Firm - action sports, snowboarding, green, tech

And sometimes, it’s warranted… I’ve heard more than a few stories from journalist friends who have told me nightmare stories of PR types stalking them incessantly, often with story ideas that just don’t fit their outlet (note:  That’s why we call it ‘Targeted Lifestyle Communications’).

Many times though, PR people can take the blame as being the bad guy and it’s really not our fault.  I was actually at a friend’s wedding where a budding young journalist from a glossy magazine said to me “I never use PR people.  They’re worthless.”  Wow… We’ve got a slew of case studies bragging proving vaguely alluding to the fact that journalists love us to death occasionally take our calls.  Anyway…

If you’ve ever worked in the tech industry, you’re probably familiar with a web magazine blog information aggregator site called Tech Crunch.  If not, keep reading, there could be some things applicable to your industry.

It seems a while back Michael Arrington had some issues with one of AOL’s senior PR people – basically he didn’t get the information he wanted, when he wanted it.

Media Bistro tells the story here.

As you can see, he’s pissed.  But is it really the PR person’s fault?

Maybe.  But maybe not.  PR typically people don’t get into the industry to become executive level information bouncers, only giving out information to the good looking journalists or those that slip us a Benjamin.

It’s the job of PR firm, consultant, etc, to advise the client on strategy and direction, as well as execution.  However, even though we’re often the gatekeepers of information, it’s not always our decision when to withhold it or not come through when a journalist has a request.  Many times, we just have to do what our clients ask.

At BBPR, like many smaller PR shops, we really try to go out of our way for journalists.  Late night calls?  No worries.  Advice on a story where our clients won’t be featured?  Happy to help, it’s what we (and many other PR people) do.

However, the following situations do happen from time to time and it’s typically not the fault of the PR person, regardless of if it’s an internal employee or external representative:

-       We can’t come through with the information you want.  Can’t… not won’t.  Maybe a client doesn’t want to be in your magazine, the request is too last minute to accommodate or a brand doesn’t like the way their competitors have been portrayed on TV.  Regardless of the reason, if we’re told by our bosses ‘no’, then the answer is no.

-       Things can be unavailable.  Unfortunately, in product PR, this happens. Before beginning a project that is product related, try to know for certain we can source something if a request.  But things happen and despite what our friends think, the BBPR office does not have a back room filled with snowboards, sneakers, eco-friendly teak furniture, beer (sorry to anyone we promised Primo to… we were told we’d have it readily available to share) or defibrillator pouches (yes, I’ve worked in the world of heart health before too).

-       Time is short and PR people need it.  Fed-Ex in Vermont and San Diego does not leave as late as it does in NYC… if you call at 7 PM on a Friday and need something shipped to a shoot for Monday AM, we may not be able to come through.  Executives that you want to interview need it too, and due to personal or professional obligations, they may not be available.

-       We have to pick and choose.  I’d like to say that all journalists will receive the same level of respect and hustle, but that’s not always feasible.  If it’s a hectic day due to a new product announcement or something else, the reporter from USA Today is going to get preferential treatment over the editor from the local weekly newspaper.  It’s unfortunate, but that’s also why in these instances, we try to put out as detailed press materials as possible.

So journalist friends, please keep in mind that while PR people are often the gatekeepers of the info you seek, we often need to call the man in the back before we open the door.

When Social Media Attacks – Green Peace vs. Nestle

Tuesday, March 23rd, 2010

killerkitkat

I love this.  Well, I don’t love that consuming Kit Kats could be environmentally detrimental, but I love the debate going on and I think we all could learn a lot.

While I’m not 100 percent in agreement with all of what Marketing Vox has to say here, I do agree with part of this excerpt:Social Media Attack exerpt 1

Having a junior person run your social media components without supervision could be horribly detrimental.  Everyone makes mistakes, (even me!), but having some senior supervision may have helped minimize the blowback here.

PR isn’t brain surgery, but it’s more than blast emails and Facebook updates too.  Having strategies in place and unfortunately, crisis plans, can help keep you on course during trying times.

If you have the time, check out another take on the battle by Switched.  Check out the comments section for an interesting, sometimes off-topic, discussion.

This post was a lot shorter than my usual ones, but I learned a lot from the links included, too much to regurgitate.  If you have some time, give’em a read.

Olympic Snowboarding And the New York Times

Tuesday, February 9th, 2010

New Shred Times

The Winter Olympics is around the corner and with it, the most important event in the history of Extreme Sports.  Ever.

Ok, I kid, but snowboarding and the Olympics are a big deal.  It may not be “core” or whatever the hot word of the moment is that describes core, but it will put snowboarding, for better or for worse, in front of gazillions quntillions zebrillions… a lot of eyeballs.

Former BBPR collaborator and eyewear marketing ninja, Liz “Bill, You Ride Too Slow” Randall forwarded me this piece from the NY Times about snowboarding progression and the Olympics.  Here’s a quick snippet if you don’t want to click the link:

NY Times Snowboarding

What we found really interesting was this call to action:

NY Times Snowboarding insert

Love it or hate it, it’s an interesting way for the NYT to try to capture a younger audience.  The paper is no stranger to running stories about extreme athletes snow-skaters radical dudes people who ride boards for a living, but this effort may bring an interesting mix of user generated content into the mix and possibly a new audience for the New York Times.

From our own experiences on this end, sourcing quality videos for a user generated video campaign is less than easy, so we’ll be interested to see how many videos are uploaded/entered into this.  The reach of the times is massive, so anything (or nothing) is possible.

Side Rant:

Like many who make their living in the world of action sports, I have mixed feelings when it comes to how the riders and activities  are portrayed in the mass media.  I’ve worked on the non-endemic side of snow-shredding since 1997 (as a part of Burton’s Cohn & Wolfe PR team – thanks again Ann!) and as a rider and marketer, I’ve seen some interesting things go down.

While it’s common place to rag on contests we think are kooky or riders who may have a more jock than rock image, think about this:  If the only people who bought <<insert your favorite brand>> products were hardcore <<insert your favorite activity>>, we’d have a lot fewer jobs in this industry.

We need to find a balance between posers fans and what we consider the core consumer, and then market to both.  Not everyone who wears a Yankees hat plays baseball and not everyone who watched the Super Bowl last Sunday actually plays the game. Non-endemic brands are almost a necessity to keep this industry going.  Turn on a baseball game and count the number of Rawlings or Wilson banners in stadiums and 30 second spots vs. how many come from baseball’s non-endemic sponsors.

Why Are Brands Underutilizing Social Media?

Thursday, January 21st, 2010

The crack team of media relations experts @ BBPR (note:  media relations vs. press release blasters – there’s a difference) have discovered one of the key reasons brands, CEOs, your parents, etc., are underutilizing social media.

Twit-Flav

Don’t let this picture deceive you.  People aren’t underutilizing social media because of my poorly Photoshopped image of the Twitter bird as Flavor Flav (original pic courtesy of Radio Grenouille).  No, they’re underutilizing social media because of TIME and MONEY (sorry, didn’t have a cool picture of money and I’ve heard defacing American currency is somewhat against the law).

More than a few media outlets have picked up on the fact that many CEOs aren’t using Twitter or other social media channels, and each week, I seem to get bombarded by a new marketing group of experts who wants me to pay to come to one of their conferences to learn how to use social media effectively.

Rant: I’m not sure how all of these people have become experts so fast or why I’m not considered one too.  After all, we’ve handled social media and digital PR strategy for brands ranging from lux auto manufacturers to furniture brands to snowboards and footwear.  Anyway….

In our experience, which I’ll say is pretty solid, the top reasons people are underutilizing social media in their marketing campaigns are time and money.

On the time front, a good campaign (and not everyone needs a good campaign… lots of people do ok with less than mediocre ones) takes effort to plan.  You can either choose to blast out Tweets and send me a Facebook update every single day about how you posted a new colorway for your Fall 2010 sock collection, or you can take the effort to put some strategy behind your program and hit the right people, at the right time, the right amount of the time.  And if you’re not a social media expert (like I am), you’re also going to need to take some time to learn about the ins and outs of these channels… factor in about a week if you’re a quick study.

The other main factor we see in brands underutilizing social media is money – human capital, finances needed to secure an outside firm to help, etc.  Although there doesn’t necessarily have to be a hard-cost media buy with social media (we’ll post later about those “pay to play” digital PR programs) execution still requires some sort of resources that you pay for in one way or another.

Your social media execution should not be left to an intern or junior colleague who is knowledgeable about what Farmville is, but won’t know how to handle negative posts, develop a strategy, see around corners, etc.  Likewise, if you have a mid-level employee manage your program, that’s adding onto their workload or taking away from another area.  There’s also the option of having a small consultancy such as BBPR or a larger firm, such as our friends at New Media Strategies back on the east coast, but regardless of who you use, expect to pay something for help executing in this “free” space.

To sum it up, yes, many brands are underutilizing social media (and probably aware of it).  At the same time, many are most likely also underutilizing advertising, press release blasting media relations, guerrilla events and their own website.  While these “experts” are well meaning, they should also take a step back and realize that utilizing social media isn’t as easy or “free” as we’d all like to think.  Heck, I haven’t updated my “free” column here on Malakye Experts & Insiders in more than a month.

A Side Note About CEO’s and Twitter

There are lots of high-level execs on Twitter.  Tony Hsieh from Zappos is a popular one and marketing guru Guy Kawasaki is another (btw – did you know he has a team of people Tweeting for him?  True story).

Does Bob McKnight have a Twitter account?  I’m not sure… nor am I sure he really needs one.  I don’t think Josh Reid from Rome SDS has one either, but those guys seem to do ok (disclosure:  I’ve worked with Rome for many years on various projects).

Brands can choose to communicate through a myriad of channels and much like with traditional advertising, what works for one brand may not feel right for another.

How To Monetize Twitter

Tuesday, December 1st, 2009

TWEET-

As much as I joke about Twitter with certain colleagues (Kim Desai, Liz Randall, I’m referring to you both), Twitter can be extremely useful.  At BBPR (blatant plug!) we regularly Tweet on behalf of certain clients in the eco, surf and NASCAR worlds.  Call it ghost tweeting, Twosting, whatever… just don’t call us social media experts, because their are enough of those on LinkedIn at the moment.

Anyway, as a marketer, I do find Twitter quite useful.  It helps me stay on top of trends and forge new relationships with journalists and passionate consumers.  While I can’t say that it’s brought my agency any direct revenue (must… not… debate… ROI…. yet…) it’s definitely helped us help clients, some of which have asked us for proposals and strategies to better use this massive time suck online platform for peer-to-crowd engagement.

Is there a way Twitter can be monetized?  Sure.  But the best one I’ve seen so far was at CostCo today during my monthly trip to buy groceries and fuel for my automobile.

Celeb-Twitter-Directory

For a mere $19.99, you can have a directory listing the @ handles for all of your… ugh, you get the idea.

Congrats Mr. Celebrity Twitter Directory Publisher.  While the owners of Twitter are searching for ways to make it profitable, you’ve beaten them to the punch in the offline world.

Who said print was dead?

Bill Byrne RSS

Bill is the lead media strategist for the San Diego based PR consultancy, BBPR. He's been helping action sports brands sell out since 1997 and occasionally delivers fantastic results for his clients. Feel free to bother him @ bill@bbpublicrelations.com. He won't publish his Twitter feed because it's boring.

Twitter @ExprtsAndNsidrs